Cookies & Brownies › Classic › Peanut Butter Cookies

Individually Wrapped Cookies - perfect for sharing! Enjoy a delicious assortme... Individually Wrapped Cookies - perfect for sharing! Enjoy a delicious assortment of individually wrapped Cheryl's cookies. OU-D. Our 36 Assorted Cookies are delivered in our signature cookie box. | 4 Chocolate Chip Cookies4 Oatmeal Raisin Cookies4... more

Our classic rich and chewy fudge brownies are made with creamery butter, evapo... Our classic rich and chewy fudge brownies are made with creamery butter, evaporated milk and loaded with chocolate chips and chocolate liquor. To complete this taste sensation, we’ve added mini peanut butter chips coated in chocolate. Then each... more

Create heartwarming memories with Taste of Home Christmas Cookies. Whether you... Create heartwarming memories with Taste of Home Christmas Cookies. Whether you re partial to cute cutouts for the kids old-time spritz or simple no-bake sweets that are ready in a snap you ll find them in this delightful cookbook. Whether you re... more

We have created the ULTIMATE box of Cheryl’s buttercream frosted cookies just ... We have created the ULTIMATE box of Cheryl’s buttercream frosted cookies just for you! This outstanding assortment includes all-time favorites like classic vanilla cut-outs and triple chocolate, our butter pecan, wedding cake cookies, key lime white... more

We have created the ULTIMATE box of Cheryl’s buttercream frosted cookies just ... We have created the ULTIMATE box of Cheryl’s buttercream frosted cookies just for you! This outstanding assortment includes all-time favorites like classic vanilla cut-outs and triple chocolate, our butter pecan, wedding cake cookies, key lime white... more

We have created the ULTIMATE box of Cheryl’s buttercream frosted cookies just ... We have created the ULTIMATE box of Cheryl’s buttercream frosted cookies just for you! This outstanding assortment includes all-time favorites like classic vanilla cut-outs and triple chocolate, our butter pecan, wedding cake cookies, key lime white... more

We have created the ULTIMATE box of Cheryl’s buttercream frosted cookies just ... We have created the ULTIMATE box of Cheryl’s buttercream frosted cookies just for you! This outstanding assortment includes all-time favorites like classic vanilla cut-outs and triple chocolate, our butter pecan, wedding cake cookies, key lime white... more

Dive into an assortment of scrumptious brownies, each one ready to make you sa... Dive into an assortment of scrumptious brownies, each one ready to make you say wow. Individually wrapped for easy sharing, there are 10 delicious flavors that range from classic fudge to toffee almond crunch to red velvet brookie. They're carefully... more

Share the best of the bakery with this four-box gift tower. Featuring a variet... Share the best of the bakery with this four-box gift tower. Featuring a variety of treats like individually wrapped butter pecan and triple chocolate buttercream-frosted cookies, snack-size crunchy chocolate chip cookies, fudge brownies, and vanilla... more

Send the bakery to someone special with this four-box gift tower. Featuring a ... Send the bakery to someone special with this four-box gift tower. Featuring a variety of treats like individually wrapped butter pecan and triple chocolate buttercream-frosted cookies, snack-size crunchy chocolate chip cookies, fudge brownies, and... more

We have created the ULTIMATE box of Cheryl’s buttercream frosted cookies just ... We have created the ULTIMATE box of Cheryl’s buttercream frosted cookies just for you! This outstanding assortment includes all-time favorites like classic vanilla cut-outs and triple chocolate, our butter pecan, wedding cake cookies, key lime white... more

Show your appreciation with the ultimate box of Cheryl’s buttercream-frosted c... Show your appreciation with the ultimate box of Cheryl’s buttercream-frosted cookies. This outstanding assortment includes all-time favorites like classic vanilla made with cutout dough, triple chocolate, butter pecan, wedding cake cookies, key lime... more

Let them know they’re on your mind with the ultimate box of Cheryl’s buttercre... Let them know they’re on your mind with the ultimate box of Cheryl’s buttercream-frosted cookies. This outstanding assortment includes all-time favorites like classic vanilla made with cutout dough, triple chocolate, butter pecan, wedding cake... more

Grant birthday wishes with the ultimate box of Cheryl’s® buttercream-frosted c... Grant birthday wishes with the ultimate box of Cheryl’s® buttercream-frosted cookies. This outstanding assortment includes all-time favorites like classic vanilla made with cutout dough, triple chocolate, butter pecan, wedding cake cookies, key lime... more

An updated and expanded edition of the bestselling Holiday Cookies featuring a... An updated and expanded edition of the bestselling Holiday Cookies featuring additional recipes from the last decade of contest winners. For nearly four decades the Chicago Tribune has run its annual Holiday Cookie Contest asking readers to submit... more

Treat your gluten-free friends to this very special gift for their big day. In... Treat your gluten-free friends to this very special gift for their big day. Included are fudge brownies, buttercream-frosted sugar cookies, and an assortment of classic cookie flavors. Everything arrives individually wrapped and freezes great, so... more

Sweeten your season with an assortment of treats all boasting the finest flavo... Sweeten your season with an assortment of treats all boasting the finest flavors of fall. We've included buttercream-frosted creations like pumpkin cookies and gold leaf cookies made with our signature cutout dough, along with tasty favorites like... more

Get the crowd cheering with a winning assortment of treats. Inside a box cover... Get the crowd cheering with a winning assortment of treats. Inside a box covered in footballs is a variety of fantastic full-size frosted and unfrosted cookies to enjoy while watching the game from home or at a sweet tailgate party. All the cookies... more

Look no further for the ultimate wow-worthy holiday gift. This jaw-dropping to... Look no further for the ultimate wow-worthy holiday gift. This jaw-dropping tower features 279 treats in total, with a delicious mix of buttercream-frosted cookies, snack-size cookies, dessert bars, pecan butterballs, peppermint pretzels, and much,... more