Cookies & Brownies › Box › Peanut Butter Cookies

Individually Wrapped Cookies - perfect for sharing! Enjoy a delicious assortme... Individually Wrapped Cookies - perfect for sharing! Enjoy a delicious assortment of individually wrapped Cheryl's cookies. OU-D. Our 36 Assorted Cookies are delivered in our signature cookie box. | 4 Chocolate Chip Cookies4 Oatmeal Raisin Cookies4... more

Our classic rich and chewy fudge brownies are made with creamery butter, evapo... Our classic rich and chewy fudge brownies are made with creamery butter, evaporated milk and loaded with chocolate chips and chocolate liquor. To complete this taste sensation, we’ve added mini peanut butter chips coated in chocolate. Then each... more

Sweeten your holiday celebration with an impressive gift. Nestled inside this ... Sweeten your holiday celebration with an impressive gift. Nestled inside this gift box is an incredible number of delicious cookies, including classics like snickerdoodles, lemon shortbreads, and double chocolate chunk. There are also cookies... more

Sharing Christmas cookies is a time-honored holiday tradition. This bountiful ... Sharing Christmas cookies is a time-honored holiday tradition. This bountiful gift includes over six dozen truly delectable gourmet cookies, perfect for family gatherings, office parties, or get-togethers with friends. Enjoy scrumptious favorites... more

Delight friends and loved ones with a tower brimming with delectable cookies f... Delight friends and loved ones with a tower brimming with delectable cookies fresh from our bakery. The assortment includes delicious chocolate chip button cookies, indulgent chocolate chocolate chunk cookies, irresistible raspberry galettes, a rich... more

We have created the ULTIMATE box of Cheryl’s buttercream frosted cookies just ... We have created the ULTIMATE box of Cheryl’s buttercream frosted cookies just for you! This outstanding assortment includes all-time favorites like classic vanilla cut-outs and triple chocolate, our butter pecan, wedding cake cookies, key lime white... more

We have created the ULTIMATE box of Cheryl’s buttercream frosted cookies just ... We have created the ULTIMATE box of Cheryl’s buttercream frosted cookies just for you! This outstanding assortment includes all-time favorites like classic vanilla cut-outs and triple chocolate, our butter pecan, wedding cake cookies, key lime white... more

We have created the ULTIMATE box of Cheryl’s buttercream frosted cookies just ... We have created the ULTIMATE box of Cheryl’s buttercream frosted cookies just for you! This outstanding assortment includes all-time favorites like classic vanilla cut-outs and triple chocolate, our butter pecan, wedding cake cookies, key lime white... more

We have created the ULTIMATE box of Cheryl’s buttercream frosted cookies just ... We have created the ULTIMATE box of Cheryl’s buttercream frosted cookies just for you! This outstanding assortment includes all-time favorites like classic vanilla cut-outs and triple chocolate, our butter pecan, wedding cake cookies, key lime white... more

Individually Wrapped Cookies - perfect for sharing! This is a rich chocolate c... Individually Wrapped Cookies - perfect for sharing! This is a rich chocolate cookie with creamy peanut butter mixed right in. Each is loaded with chocolate chips and mini peanut butter cups. We top this amazing cookie with our delicious peanut... more

Individually Wrapped Cookies - perfect for sharing! Our soft and delicious pea... Individually Wrapped Cookies - perfect for sharing! Our soft and delicious peanut butter cookie is made with real peanut butter, brown sugar, and fresh roasted peanuts. Best of all, we then add a generous layer of fudge buttercream frosting topped... more

Brighten anyone’s day with a sweet and thoughtful gift. Among the goodies is a... Brighten anyone’s day with a sweet and thoughtful gift. Among the goodies is a mouthwatering selection of brownies including fudge, caramel fudge, and peanut butter-frosted buckeye. These treats are accompanied by even more delicious dessert bars in... more

Brighten anyone’s day with a sweet and thoughtful gift. Among the goodies is a... Brighten anyone’s day with a sweet and thoughtful gift. Among the goodies is a mouthwatering selection of brownies including fudge, caramel fudge, and peanut butter-frosted buckeye. These treats are accompanied by even more delicious dessert bars in... more

Send a sweet gesture of your appreciation with a thoughtful gift of one dozen ... Send a sweet gesture of your appreciation with a thoughtful gift of one dozen irresistible cookies. They'll love exploring all six flavors, including cookies & cream, peanut butter buckeye, lemon burst, and more-each of which is topped with our... more

Send a sweet gesture of your appreciation with a thoughtful gift of one dozen ... Send a sweet gesture of your appreciation with a thoughtful gift of one dozen irresistible cookies. They'll love exploring all six flavors, including cookies & cream, peanut butter buckeye, lemon burst, and more-each of which is topped with our... more

Share the best of the bakery with this four-box gift tower. Featuring a variet... Share the best of the bakery with this four-box gift tower. Featuring a variety of treats like individually wrapped butter pecan and triple chocolate buttercream-frosted cookies, snack-size crunchy chocolate chip cookies, fudge brownies, and vanilla... more

Send the bakery to someone special with this four-box gift tower. Featuring a ... Send the bakery to someone special with this four-box gift tower. Featuring a variety of treats like individually wrapped butter pecan and triple chocolate buttercream-frosted cookies, snack-size crunchy chocolate chip cookies, fudge brownies, and... more

We have created the ULTIMATE box of Cheryl’s buttercream frosted cookies just ... We have created the ULTIMATE box of Cheryl’s buttercream frosted cookies just for you! This outstanding assortment includes all-time favorites like classic vanilla cut-outs and triple chocolate, our butter pecan, wedding cake cookies, key lime white... more

Show your appreciation with the ultimate box of Cheryl’s buttercream-frosted c... Show your appreciation with the ultimate box of Cheryl’s buttercream-frosted cookies. This outstanding assortment includes all-time favorites like classic vanilla made with cutout dough, triple chocolate, butter pecan, wedding cake cookies, key lime... more

Let them know they’re on your mind with the ultimate box of Cheryl’s buttercre... Let them know they’re on your mind with the ultimate box of Cheryl’s buttercream-frosted cookies. This outstanding assortment includes all-time favorites like classic vanilla made with cutout dough, triple chocolate, butter pecan, wedding cake... more