Cookies & Brownies › Box › Butter Cookies

A timeless Cheryl’s classic! Our soft and chewy cookies were developed from an... A timeless Cheryl’s classic! Our soft and chewy cookies were developed from an old-fashioned cut-out cookie recipe and have become a customer favorite for almost 40 years. Each individually wrapped cookie is layered with our famous buttercream... more

Individually Wrapped Cookies - perfect for sharing! Our rich chocolate cookies... Individually Wrapped Cookies - perfect for sharing! Our rich chocolate cookies are made with two kinds of cocoa, semi-sweet chocolate chips and caramel chunks and best of all, we mix creamy caramel sauce right into the dough. Each treat is finished... more

These delicious chocolate cookies are made with the addition of rich black coc... These delicious chocolate cookies are made with the addition of rich black cocoa and topped with our vanilla buttercream frosting. Each treat is finished with crushed chocolate and vanilla cream cookies making it one of our new favorites! Our yummy... more

Enjoy a delectable cookie that's the flavor of a classic cake. This German cho... Enjoy a delectable cookie that's the flavor of a classic cake. This German chocolate cookie is created with a cakey chocolate base before being frosted with caramel buttercream frosting that's mixed with coconut. Pieces of crunchy pecan are... more

Individually Wrapped Cookies - perfect for sharing! A classic fall flavor comb... Individually Wrapped Cookies - perfect for sharing! A classic fall flavor combination baked into a yummy cookie! Our buttery brown sugar cookie dough is made with graham cracker crumbs and loaded with milk chocolate and tasty little marshmallow... more

Individually Wrapped Cookies - perfect for sharing! Celebrate your fall occasi... Individually Wrapped Cookies - perfect for sharing! Celebrate your fall occasions with our individually wrapped buttercream frosted cinnamon pumpkin cookies! Our cookies are delivered in a bow gift box and guaranteed to brighten everyone’s day. This... more

Enjoy the cookie version of a classic, fruity combination. The base cookie is ... Enjoy the cookie version of a classic, fruity combination. The base cookie is created with orange marmalade and dried cranberries, making it sweet and delicate. Our buttercream frosting is flavored with cranberry before being piped on top for a... more

Ring in the festivities with a tasty, wintertime cookie. Our gingerbread cooki... Ring in the festivities with a tasty, wintertime cookie. Our gingerbread cookie is made with a delicious combination of crystallized ginger, molasses, and cloves. It's baked to perfection before being frosted with our classic buttercream frosting. A... more

Individually Wrapped Cookies - perfect for sharing! Real lemon peel and the re... Individually Wrapped Cookies - perfect for sharing! Real lemon peel and the refreshing zest of lemon extract make this a very popular cookie! Our lemon buttercream frosting has just the right amount of flavor and blends perfectly with our soft and... more

SAVE UP TO 42%! Don't let the cookie jar go empty! Instead have a box of our u... SAVE UP TO 42%! Don't let the cookie jar go empty! Instead have a box of our unparalleled buttercream frosted cut-out cookies delivered right to your (or one of your favorite people's) door every month or every other other month. Each delivery... more

SAVE UP TO 42%! Don't let the cookie jar go empty! Instead have a box of our u... SAVE UP TO 42%! Don't let the cookie jar go empty! Instead have a box of our unparalleled buttercream frosted cut-out cookies delivered right to your (or one of your favorite people's) door every month or every other other month. Each delivery... more

SAVE UP TO 40%!Don't let the cookie jar go empty! Instead have a box of our un... SAVE UP TO 40%!Don't let the cookie jar go empty! Instead have a box of our unparalleled buttercream frosted cut-out cookies delivered right to your (or one of your favorite people's) door every or every other month. Each delivery includes 24... more

SAVE UP TO 40%!Don't let the cookie jar go empty! Instead have a box of our un... SAVE UP TO 40%!Don't let the cookie jar go empty! Instead have a box of our unparalleled buttercream frosted cut-out cookies delivered right to your (or one of your favorite people's) door every or every other month. Each delivery includes 24... more

Celebrate the holidays with a pop of festive flavor. This cookie is created wi... Celebrate the holidays with a pop of festive flavor. This cookie is created with a soft, peppermint-flavored sugar cookie base before being topped with pink, peppermint buttercream frosting and decorated with colorful sprinkles and edible glitter. A... more

We’ve taken our classic chocolate chip cookie, baked it to perfection, and top... We’ve taken our classic chocolate chip cookie, baked it to perfection, and topped it with a generous layer of our famous vanilla buttercream frosting. Best of all, we’ve topped this tasty baked treat with cookie dough pieces. It's just like licking... more

This buttery cinnamon sugar cookie tastes just like a real cinnamon roll! Best... This buttery cinnamon sugar cookie tastes just like a real cinnamon roll! Best of all, each soft and delicious cookie is finished with our cream cheese flavored frosting and brown sugar streusel topping. We’ve individually wrapped each baked treat... more

Wow! This flavorful cookie is quickly becoming one of our fall favorites! We u... Wow! This flavorful cookie is quickly becoming one of our fall favorites! We use real maple syrup and honey and lots of brown sugar, butter, and vanilla topped with a generous layer of maple buttercream frosting. Each soft and rich treat is... more

When you bite into this soft and refreshing cookie a delicious burst of orange... When you bite into this soft and refreshing cookie a delicious burst of orange invades your mouth! Each cookie is made with real crushed orange and layered with our famous buttercream frosting with just a touch of natural orange citrus flavoring and... more

Attention Key Lime Lovers! Our summer sampler includes 12 individually wrapped... Attention Key Lime Lovers! Our summer sampler includes 12 individually wrapped key lime cookies. This outstanding soft and chewy cookie is loaded with white chocolate chips and layered with a sweet buttercream frosting flavored with just the right... more

We have created the ULTIMATE box of Cheryl’s buttercream frosted cookies just ... We have created the ULTIMATE box of Cheryl’s buttercream frosted cookies just for you! This outstanding assortment includes all-time favorites like classic vanilla cut-outs and triple chocolate, our butter pecan, wedding cake cookies, key lime white... more