Reviews for Blue Nile Garnet Cushion Earrings in Sterling Silver


Product Reviews (44)

Absolutely love them.

Absolutely love them.

By Tammy on Blue Nile - Feb 17, 2014

Beyond my expectations!

Beautiful stone. Quality design.

By Anonymous on Blue Nile - Feb 12, 2014

disapointing quality

The product showed up in a bag, the posts were bent, I was however able to re straighten them without breaking them, still disappointing quality

By Anonymous on Blue Nile - Jan 28, 2014

Definitely Satisfied

Christmas present. They were very well received. Received on time and everything was processed efficiently. Have used BN for 5 yrs. and will continue.

By Anonymous on Blue Nile - Jan 5, 2014

Great earrings -- tiny backings.

These are beautiful large earrings. Stones this size could use the larger backings to feel securely in place, and easier to put on and take off.

By ALDONA on Blue Nile - Jan 2, 2014

she loves them

Beautiful and affordable quality

By Nathanael on Blue Nile - Dec 24, 2013

Love the earrings!!

Beautiful earrings. Worth every penny. Very affordable.

By Anonymous on Blue Nile - Dec 13, 2013

Love these earrings!

This is my third pair of gemstone earrings in this style from Blue Nile! I now have the garnet, London blue topaz and the amethyst. I love them all - but I think the garnets may be my favorite. They are the perfect shade of 'garnet' red. The stones are substantial, and very high quality.

By Anonymous on Blue Nile - Nov 18, 2013

This cut goes with anything.

These are awesome earrings. Great color and size. A very good value.

By Anonymous on Blue Nile - Aug 9, 2013

Garnets for her graduation ...

I bought these for my granddaughter's graduation. They are stunning, with deep color and beautiful fire. I know they'll be a treasured heirloom. A very good value and a perfect gift.

By Anonymous on Blue Nile - May 31, 2013

Perfect Gift!

I have purchased several of these cushion cut gemstone earrings in just about every gemstone type Blue Nile has and I have never been disappointed. The size is substantial, the color is always rich and the price is perfect. These earrings are fantastic and I highly recommend them to anyone looking for the perfect gift for any occasion!

By Anonymous on Blue Nile - Apr 12, 2013

Very Nice!

She says...very pretty, beautiful color, and just nice...she needs more clothes to go with them!

By ANTHONY on Blue Nile - Mar 5, 2013

Exceptional Purchase

Very pleased with the earings. Much larger than I expected them to be. She loves them and how they look, very classsy.... I will be shopping for the matching necklace, also.

By Anonymous on Blue Nile - Feb 26, 2013

She loved them!

Ordered for Valentine's Day. Arrived on time and in perfect condition.

By kevin on Blue Nile - Feb 22, 2013

My wife loves it when I shop Blue Nile!

Very pleased with size and quality. Great value compared to what I saw shopping local jewelry stores.

By Anonymous on Blue Nile - Feb 22, 2013

Beautiful earrings!!

Stunning earrings! My mother loved them. They were a perfect size and great quality!

By Anonymous on Blue Nile - Jan 22, 2013


They are a good size. Only bad thing is I'm not sure how many carats they are. I also bought the matching necklace.

By Anonymous on Blue Nile - Jan 17, 2013

My granddaughter thought they were perfect!

To be perfectly honest, when I opened the box, I was very surprised at their size. I was expecting them to be very small and they were not. I actually wondered if my granddaughter would think they were too big; but, she loved them. They were perfect!

By Lorraine on Blue Nile - Jan 7, 2013

Beautiful earrings

Beautiful color and great size. Exceptional quality.

By Kathy on Blue Nile - Nov 22, 2012

Beautiful garnets

Color is a deep, rich garnet. Stones are large, but the measurements are included in the description so I was expecting that.

By Anonymous on Blue Nile - Sep 21, 2012

Love em, bought the Amathyst too

After reading the other comments I decided to go with these earrings. I wasn't convinced though that they would actually be bigger than expected. Well, I was wrong...the stone is very nice, very visible.

By Kimberly on Blue Nile - May 21, 2012

Very nice!

Great value and looks great. Wife is very happy

By Anonymous on Blue Nile - May 8, 2012

Great size...she loved them!

These are great...she loved them. Look really classy and are nice and big. Will get some of the others with different stones in the future.

By Anonymous on Blue Nile - Feb 25, 2012

Valentine's gift for my Daughter

Gave these earrings to my daughter for Valentine's Day and she loves them. The stones have a brilliant deep luster and sparkle to them. Nice gift for a good price.

By Anonymous on Blue Nile - Feb 24, 2012

These might even replace my go-to diamond studs!

The size is larger than I expected and the first day I wore them, I received so many positive compliments! People loved the interesting facets to the garnet, both reflecting light and showing the rich, red shades.

By Anonymous on Blue Nile - Feb 23, 2012

Loving these earrings.

They are just the right size for my ears.

By Kay on Blue Nile - Feb 23, 2012

Very nice

Arrived on time. Looked more expensive then appeared in pictures

By Edward on Blue Nile - Feb 23, 2012


Bought from you in the past. Perfect set of earrings.

By Richard on Blue Nile - Feb 23, 2012

She loved the earings..

Very nice ear rings...much better than the picture.

By Rusty on Blue Nile - Feb 23, 2012

She loves them!

She loves them, and has not taken them off yet! They will go great with all of her Gamecock gear too!

By Anonymous on Blue Nile - Feb 23, 2012

She really liked them !

larger then I expected, excellent studs / backs

By Anonymous on Blue Nile - Feb 23, 2012

Look great, great value

Earring were very well received.

By Anonymous on Blue Nile - Feb 23, 2012

My daughter wants my earrings

The earrings were exceptional and look great on too! I have received many compliments and my daughter wants them. I am very happy with the quality and size of the stone.

By Rafaela on Blue Nile - Feb 23, 2012

Great confirmation present.

Great product! highly recommended!

By Monika on Blue Nile - Feb 20, 2012

Beautiful January Birthstone


By Dana on Blue Nile - Feb 18, 2012

She loved them!

My girlfriend loved the earrings! She has had numerous compliments on how the garnets sparkle in the sun. The item was delivered on the exact day listed. I will definitely be using Blue Nile for all my future jewelry shopping, especially the big one I plan to purchase pretty soon!

By Anonymous on Blue Nile - Feb 17, 2012

Great birthday gift!

My DIL loved them! She said that they sparkle and catch the light and are an incredible shade of red, she was very pleased!

By Anonymous on Blue Nile - Jan 17, 2012

Gorgeous eye-catchers!

Stunning red color (slightly more blue than orange), generous size, pretty silver setting. Bought these for my January birthday mom and she LOVES them!

By Anonymous on Blue Nile - Jan 5, 2012


these are substantial studs

By Jana on Blue Nile - Dec 30, 2011

She loves these earrings

She loves these earrings

By Anonymous on Blue Nile - Dec 30, 2011


Purchased these for a gift and after seeing them in person, might have to order a pair for myself! They're much larger than i expected and the color is stunning.

By Anonymous on Blue Nile - Dec 22, 2011

Love my birthday present.

Lovely earrings, much larger than I expected and very good quality garnets. I am very pleased iwth my purchase.

By Anonymous on Blue Nile - Dec 22, 2011


These earrings drew compliments the first time I wore them. The color has depth and the cut subtle sparkle. They are easily worn all day, dressed up and down, a real classic.

By Susan on Blue Nile - Dec 12, 2011

She was very happy!

These are sizeable earrings that look great. It's the first garnet jewelry I've bought from Blue Nile and I couldn't have been more pleased with it. Neither could my wife!

By Anonymous on Blue Nile - Dec 12, 2011