Garnet Hill Gabriella Leather Riding Boots - 09 - Black Leather

MPN: 27499BKLT9
Product Details
Description
This refined Italian leather riding boot is more on-trend and more comfortable than ever. Inspired by the equestrian set, it offers an updated fit with elastic gores at the top, increased room in the toe box and a reshaped shaft that follows the curve of the calf. Boot top slants slightly toward the back, in true equestrian style. Two straps with nickel hardware. 15 1/2 in. shaft; 1 in. heel. Full-zip closure. Man-made sole.
Quick Glance
Shoe/boot Type Riding
Material Leather
Color Red
User Reviews
These Boots look and feel amazing!
4 Star Review   By Mathgirl on Garnet Hill - Nov 21, 2013   

I took the advice and ordered a half size up, so the boots fit just fine. They are comfortable and good-looking. There is enough room to tuck in pants if you wish. Good value at the sale price.

Was this review helpful to you?  Yes or No ( Report this as inappropriate )

nice boots
4 Star Review   By crlyd on Garnet Hill - Nov 15, 2013   

I bought these for my daughter. She said they are very comfortable and she wears them all the time. They are well made and hopefully will wear well.

100% of readers found this review helpful.

Was this review helpful to you?  Yes or No ( Report this as inappropriate )

Not the best leather
2 Star Review   By Littleredcar on Garnet Hill - Apr 20, 2013   

I saw these boots on sale and they were exactly what I had been looking for! The leather is great quality and the grey color perfect, but I wore them one time and the left boot was extremely uncomfortable and painful when I walked. They are beautiful boots, but I will have to return them.

Was this review helpful to you?  Yes or No ( Report this as inappropriate )

Classic Riding Boots
5 Star Review   By HorseGirls on Garnet Hill - Apr 1, 2013   

great looking, rich soft leather. super comfortable. fantastic value at sale price. but still good value at regular price

Was this review helpful to you?  Yes or No ( Report this as inappropriate )

Great boots !
5 Star Review   By Trlong on Garnet Hill - Mar 31, 2013   

I love the dark brown color and leather quality. very soft and also look very stylish. I don't regret any of my purchase from Garnet Hill. Excellent customer service when I have questions. My size is 6 and 1/2 and 7 fit perfectly.

100% of readers found this review helpful.

Was this review helpful to you?  Yes or No ( Report this as inappropriate )

Great boots...just not for me
5 Star Review   By clgn on Garnet Hill - Mar 23, 2013   

Comfortable/stylish- fit great/versitle use dress up or jeans.

Was this review helpful to you?  Yes or No ( Report this as inappropriate )

Great boots - great value!
4 Star Review   By 1bootlover on Garnet Hill - Mar 22, 2013   

I have been looking for a classic pair of black riding boots and I'm so happy I found these. I followed the advice of previous purchasers and sized up a half size and they fit perfect.No problem with my 15in. calves. If I had to change one thing it would be to add a cushioned footbed. I'm on my feet a lot during the day . Otherwise I love them.

Was this review helpful to you?  Yes or No ( Report this as inappropriate )

Nice boots, nice leather!
5 Star Review   By Raine on Garnet Hill - Mar 21, 2013   

I bought these for my 26 year old daughter after she'd told me she was looking for a nice pair of brown boots, so ordered them for her birthday. She LOVES them!---said they were a great fit (I'd ordered 1/2 size up as recommended and that was perfect) look great for both dressy and dressed-down looks. Nice boot!

Was this review helpful to you?  Yes or No ( Report this as inappropriate )

These Boots look and feel amazing!
4 Star Review   By justmelh on Garnet Hill - Mar 9, 2013   

I've been looking for gray boots for a couple of years. These fit the bill: low heel, great color, great leather. So when they went on sale I jumped on them. I'm glad I ordered up. A little hard to get into, but once on fit good. The difficulty in getting them on is the only reason I didn't rate them a 5.

Was this review helpful to you?  Yes or No ( Report this as inappropriate )

Wonderful Boot
5 Star Review   By dunnsriver62 on Garnet Hill - Mar 4, 2013   

Was so excited to receive my new riding boots and they are simply wonderful! I ordered up, usually wear 8.5 and got the size 9 and they are perfect. Very comfortable and stylish too!!

Was this review helpful to you?  Yes or No ( Report this as inappropriate )

Product Details
Description
This refined Italian leather riding boot is more on-trend and more comfortable than ever. Inspired by the equestrian set, it offers an updated fit with elastic gores at the top, increased room in the toe box and a reshaped shaft that follows the curve of the calf. Boot top slants slightly toward the back, in true equestrian style. Two straps with nickel hardware. 15 1/2 in. shaft; 1 in. heel. Full-zip closure. Man-made sole.
Quick Glance
Shoe/boot Type Riding
Material Leather
Color Red
Summary
Product Title Garnet Hill Gabriella Leather Riding Boots - 09 - Black Leather
Manufacturer Garnet Hill
Power Score 4.2 | 84 Reviews
Additional Specifications
Long john type: sets, tops
bra features: back closure
bra style: Sports and Outdoors
Gender: Women
Age: adults
Loungewear style: tops
User Reviews
These Boots look and feel amazing!
4 Star Review   By Mathgirl on Garnet Hill - Nov 21, 2013   

I took the advice and ordered a half size up, so the boots fit just fine. They are comfortable and good-looking. There is enough room to tuck in pants if you wish. Good value at the sale price.

Was this review helpful to you?  Yes or No ( Report this as inappropriate )

nice boots
4 Star Review   By crlyd on Garnet Hill - Nov 15, 2013   

I bought these for my daughter. She said they are very comfortable and she wears them all the time. They are well made and hopefully will wear well.

100% of readers found this review helpful.

Was this review helpful to you?  Yes or No ( Report this as inappropriate )

Not the best leather
2 Star Review   By Littleredcar on Garnet Hill - Apr 20, 2013   

I saw these boots on sale and they were exactly what I had been looking for! The leather is great quality and the grey color perfect, but I wore them one time and the left boot was extremely uncomfortable and painful when I walked. They are beautiful boots, but I will have to return them.

Was this review helpful to you?  Yes or No ( Report this as inappropriate )

Classic Riding Boots
5 Star Review   By HorseGirls on Garnet Hill - Apr 1, 2013   

great looking, rich soft leather. super comfortable. fantastic value at sale price. but still good value at regular price

Was this review helpful to you?  Yes or No ( Report this as inappropriate )

Great boots !
5 Star Review   By Trlong on Garnet Hill - Mar 31, 2013   

I love the dark brown color and leather quality. very soft and also look very stylish. I don't regret any of my purchase from Garnet Hill. Excellent customer service when I have questions. My size is 6 and 1/2 and 7 fit perfectly.

100% of readers found this review helpful.

Was this review helpful to you?  Yes or No ( Report this as inappropriate )

Great boots...just not for me
5 Star Review   By clgn on Garnet Hill - Mar 23, 2013   

Comfortable/stylish- fit great/versitle use dress up or jeans.

Was this review helpful to you?  Yes or No ( Report this as inappropriate )

Great boots - great value!
4 Star Review   By 1bootlover on Garnet Hill - Mar 22, 2013   

I have been looking for a classic pair of black riding boots and I'm so happy I found these. I followed the advice of previous purchasers and sized up a half size and they fit perfect.No problem with my 15in. calves. If I had to change one thing it would be to add a cushioned footbed. I'm on my feet a lot during the day . Otherwise I love them.

Was this review helpful to you?  Yes or No ( Report this as inappropriate )

Nice boots, nice leather!
5 Star Review   By Raine on Garnet Hill - Mar 21, 2013   

I bought these for my 26 year old daughter after she'd told me she was looking for a nice pair of brown boots, so ordered them for her birthday. She LOVES them!---said they were a great fit (I'd ordered 1/2 size up as recommended and that was perfect) look great for both dressy and dressed-down looks. Nice boot!

Was this review helpful to you?  Yes or No ( Report this as inappropriate )

These Boots look and feel amazing!
4 Star Review   By justmelh on Garnet Hill - Mar 9, 2013   

I've been looking for gray boots for a couple of years. These fit the bill: low heel, great color, great leather. So when they went on sale I jumped on them. I'm glad I ordered up. A little hard to get into, but once on fit good. The difficulty in getting them on is the only reason I didn't rate them a 5.

Was this review helpful to you?  Yes or No ( Report this as inappropriate )

Wonderful Boot
5 Star Review   By dunnsriver62 on Garnet Hill - Mar 4, 2013   

Was so excited to receive my new riding boots and they are simply wonderful! I ordered up, usually wear 8.5 and got the size 9 and they are perfect. Very comfortable and stylish too!!

Was this review helpful to you?  Yes or No ( Report this as inappropriate )

Lovely boots!!!
4 Star Review   By NDno1 on Garnet Hill - Mar 2, 2013   

The boots are great, and at the sale price, an incredibly good value. But you should size up one full size, because the boots tend to be really narrow. I read the other comments and ordered accordingly.

100% of readers found this review helpful.

Was this review helpful to you?  Yes or No ( Report this as inappropriate )

Not as desribed
4 Star Review   By Hedley on Garnet Hill - Mar 1, 2013   

The boots ran very narrow, will return, but super cute!

100% of readers found this review helpful.

Was this review helpful to you?  Yes or No ( Report this as inappropriate )

Beautiful boots-- go with the fit advice
5 Star Review   By vamom1 on Garnet Hill - Feb 21, 2013   

Excellent boots. I wear size 8 and ordered 1/2 size up and they fit perfect. Very comfortable and are as beautiful as the pitcture. I wore them with skinny jeans and got many compliments.

Was this review helpful to you?  Yes or No ( Report this as inappropriate )

Elegant Boots
5 Star Review   By GoPackGo on Garnet Hill - Feb 15, 2013   

I love the look of these boots and the lightweight feel. I have a medium to narrow foot and a 15 1/4 inch calf with a high arch and narrow heels. They were a little bit of a struggle at first but after wearing them around the house for 1/2 hour, they felt great and I was able to zip them over my skinny jeans. I won't be able to wear them with heavy socks unless they stretch a little more. I normally wear a 9 1/2 shoe and bought a 10 as recommended. I hope they stretch a bit more to accommodate wool socks. I love the look of the foot bed - very narrow and feminine. The heel fits nice and snug which I believe is a sign of a well-made boot because it keeps your foot in the proper position - nearly all shoes are to big in the heels for me.

100% of readers found this review helpful.

Was this review helpful to you?  Yes or No ( Report this as inappropriate )

Great Purchase
1 Star Review   By Koko22 on Garnet Hill - Feb 15, 2013   

Was excited to find a classic riding boot in gray. I'm a regular to narrow width. Always an 8.5. I ordered a 9 based on the recommendations. I thought that they would work well as many reviews noted that the calf was a tight fit & i have an have an average sized calf 12" in circumference. The leather was nice & supple, the color great. The sole was the first turn off. It was man made and looked cheap. My husbands fist thought was that the sole would wear quickly & be very slippery. When I tried them on they were tight across the top of my foot. Very narrow in the toe box. They pinched. Wide in the heel & HUGE in the calf, sloppy. Very sad to send these back. They photographed better than the actual product. Very disappointed. Ill stick to boots/shoes w/leather soles.

Was this review helpful to you?  Yes or No ( Report this as inappropriate )

Lovely boot for large calves
5 Star Review   By AdamAlexStyle on Garnet Hill - Feb 15, 2013   

BEST BOOTS EVER. THE QUALITY OF THE LEATHER IS SECOND TO NONE. IT HAS THE GREAT SMELL.

Was this review helpful to you?  Yes or No ( Report this as inappropriate )

boots
5 Star Review   By luvtoshopinillinois on Garnet Hill - Feb 12, 2013   

Bit skeptical after reading a few reviews BUT, I love these boots. I ordered my normal size and they fit fine, 5"4 150# and medium calves and the calf diameter fit perfectly. Soft leather, comfortable and versatile. Great buy!

Was this review helpful to you?  Yes or No ( Report this as inappropriate )

Beautiful Boots
2 Star Review   By Shirleyb on Garnet Hill - Feb 7, 2013   

I wanted to like these. I purchased in black on sale. The look and quality of the boot was nice but when I put them on, it was so unforcomfortable by the calf. When I zippered them up, my leg couldn't breathe. Unfortunately, I had to return.

Was this review helpful to you?  Yes or No ( Report this as inappropriate )

Comfortable and Stylish
5 Star Review   By VTSoccerMom on Garnet Hill - Feb 5, 2013   

These are wonderful boots for the price. The leather is soft and luxurious and they are very well made. This is the second pair of GH boots I bought and they really are quality boots, through and through. I ordered a 1/2 size up, as I sometimes do with tall boots and I was glad I did.

Was this review helpful to you?  Yes or No ( Report this as inappropriate )

Gorgeous -but very tall
5 Star Review   By GMCB on Garnet Hill - Feb 5, 2013   

These boots are gorgeous - lovely leather and styling. They fit quite well in width, having sized up. Unfortunately, they were too tall for my 5'3" self. I have large feet for my size (10) - in a small size they may be fine for shorter people.

Was this review helpful to you?  Yes or No ( Report this as inappropriate )

Great boots
4 Star Review   By Poody on Garnet Hill - Feb 5, 2013   

I initially ordered a 1/2 size bigger but exchanged them for a full size larger. Now that I've worn them once they are really too big. Wish I would have kept the 1/2 size bigger and worn them. Love them 'tho. Have already had many compliments on them.

Was this review helpful to you?  Yes or No ( Report this as inappropriate )

Gabrella Boots
3 Star Review   By tortoise on Garnet Hill - Feb 5, 2013   

Nice leather boot. Comfortable. Unfortunately does not fit my calf. Never thought that I had large calf's, but I guess I do. Unfortunately, these boots must go back. Too bad that these boots do not come in a wider calf size. I would definitely purchase them.

Was this review helpful to you?  Yes or No ( Report this as inappropriate )

Great Boots
5 Star Review   By ValNM on Garnet Hill - Feb 5, 2013   

I love these boots. The leather is rich and they look great with skinny jeans. I'm so glad I read the reviews because they really are narrow. I ordered a full size up and I still need to break them in a bit. That said, I couldn't be happier with this purchase.

Was this review helpful to you?  Yes or No ( Report this as inappropriate )

Beautiful boots!
3 Star Review   By cali33 on Garnet Hill - Feb 5, 2013   

I am a size 6 and these were just a tad too big on me. I normally deal with this by wearing a thicker sock, but even after putting one on, after just walking to the bedroom to look at them in the mirror, my foot hurt on the top, where the natural "crease" made by walking bends the boot to accommodate. The leather is not supple, and I know that crease pain would bother me for sure. Sending it back.

Was this review helpful to you?  Yes or No ( Report this as inappropriate )

For larger calves
4 Star Review   By MimiinWNC on Garnet Hill - Feb 5, 2013   

I ordered these and they were pretty cute on. The calves were large on me so I ended up sending them back,

Was this review helpful to you?  Yes or No ( Report this as inappropriate )

These run very small
3 Star Review   By timeflys767 on Garnet Hill - Feb 5, 2013   

i normally wear a size 8 going by the reviews bought 8.5 they are still very tight

Was this review helpful to you?  Yes or No ( Report this as inappropriate )

Very Beautiful Boot
5 Star Review   By Boilersusie on Garnet Hill - Feb 3, 2013   

I love these boots. I ordered up a 1/2 size as recommended, and the boots fit perfectly!! No breaking in required - you can wear them all day long the first time you put them on. Look great with skirts, leggings, and jeans. Buying them on sale made them even better!!!!!

Was this review helpful to you?  Yes or No ( Report this as inappropriate )

beautiful boot
5 Star Review   By loveLP on Garnet Hill - Feb 2, 2013   

I loved these boots!! They were everythng I wanted, but unfortunately they didn't have a size bigger like they recommended and I took a chance hoping my size would fit, but way too small. So I had to send them back. Size 10 was way too small, and usually size 10 is a bit too big, so order the next size. It was a huge disappointment for me!!

Was this review helpful to you?  Yes or No ( Report this as inappropriate )

BEST BOOTS EVER
5 Star Review   By Dakkusa on Garnet Hill - Jan 26, 2013   

I love these boots! I ordered the black, and the leather is scrumptious. They have an elegant look, and are very comfortable. I did order a half size up, and they fit fine. Only thing, I am medium build, dress size 8-10, with what I thought were "normal" calves...these boots (unlike what most reviewers said) are snug at the top of my calves....so will only be wearing with skirts/tights and leggings - but that's fine...just love them! Got them on sale too: win-win!

Was this review helpful to you?  Yes or No ( Report this as inappropriate )

just too wide on calf
5 Star Review   By ShoesforLes on Garnet Hill - Jan 26, 2013   

I love my new boots!!!!!!!! I followed the recommendation that I order a half size larger and they fit beautifully! I am thrilled with them.

Was this review helpful to you?  Yes or No ( Report this as inappropriate )

LOVE these boots!
4 Star Review   By LTMGSJD on Garnet Hill - Jan 21, 2013   

Beautiful boots but they hit my ankle bone incorrectly and they were too big in the calves. Sizing up was smart... I am a 6.5 but ordered a 7. I have a small frame so they just did not work for me so I had to return them unfortunately. Got them on sale so they were well worth the sale price.

Was this review helpful to you?  Yes or No ( Report this as inappropriate )

Awesome boots!
3 Star Review   By Carol80457 on Garnet Hill - Jan 21, 2013   

These boots are very attractive, and it is good to have three choices of color. They do run very narrow, I have regular width feet (on the narrower side), and the width is snug on me. I did order them a half size up, but they are still snug. I will wear them mostly with tights, rather than thicker socks. I bought them on sale, but had I paid full price for them I would have been slightly disappointed in the thickness and softness of the leather. They were a good value at the sale price, however.

Was this review helpful to you?  Yes or No ( Report this as inappropriate )

Gorgeous boots!
5 Star Review   By AudreyC on Garnet Hill - Jan 21, 2013   

I am so happy to have found these boots. They are comfortable and stylish. They walk the talk from marble floors to snowy streets. Nice addition to the collection and a great value.

Was this review helpful to you?  Yes or No ( Report this as inappropriate )

Second of same
4 Star Review   By Oscard0g on Garnet Hill - Jan 21, 2013   

I had purchased a pair of brown Gabriella boots earlier in the year, as I needed a low heel. When I realized I needed black boots, I purchased a second pair.

Was this review helpful to you?  Yes or No ( Report this as inappropriate )

Beautiful, But Beware of Fit
5 Star Review   By julias on Garnet Hill - Jan 19, 2013   

The brown color of these is so rich (better looking than in the photo), and the buckles are sophisticated! I loved them right out of the box, and was delighted that I took the reviewers' advice to go up a half size! Perfect fit! Wish I could get all three colors!

Was this review helpful to you?  Yes or No ( Report this as inappropriate )

GREAT BOOTS!
5 Star Review   By LizAnn on Garnet Hill - Jan 16, 2013   

Wanted a pair of grey leather boots,saw these and had to have them. Very comfortable and the color is perfect. Also went the half size up, wore them to work all day without any discomfort.

Was this review helpful to you?  Yes or No ( Report this as inappropriate )

Perfect Boots
5 Star Review   By maevet on Garnet Hill - Jan 15, 2013   

I ordered these boots a half size bigger as recommended and they fit me perfectly. They are great with skirts and tights and they go over jeans as well. They have just enough detail to make them interesting but not fussy. I am very happy with my purchase.

Was this review helpful to you?  Yes or No ( Report this as inappropriate )

Good value but bad fit
2 Star Review   By WVLady on Garnet Hill - Jan 7, 2013   

The picture of this boot looks great, however, the fit didn't work for me. I'm pretty average, and generally able to wear just about any boot. The calf on these is extremely large, and the suggestion to order a size up was a mistake for me. Probably would have reordered them in my normal size 7 1/2 if the boot would have fit my calf better. I was also a little dissapointed in the leather as it was thinner than I had anticipated. Was hoping for the perfect equestrian riding boot, but sadly, they're on their way back.

Was this review helpful to you?  Yes or No ( Report this as inappropriate )

Review of my riding boots
3 Star Review   By maresydoats on Garnet Hill - Jan 7, 2013   

The Gabriella boots are truly beautiful, well made and...too narrow. I'm tall and slender with normal to narrow width feet. I went a full size above my normal shoe size (as recommended on the website) to be able to get my foot into the boot (the 1/2 size upsize wasn't enough). My disappointment came in with the realization that the boot width, would become painful in a very short amount of time. I was so sad...I've been looking for a sophisticated, well made, well priced boot for over a year and these boots fit the bill, but I had to return them.

Was this review helpful to you?  Yes or No ( Report this as inappropriate )

Cutest boots!!
4 Star Review   By Catalina on Garnet Hill - Jan 1, 2013   

These boots are beautiful. The quality is excellent. However, they run extremely narrow. Do not order them if you do not have a narrow foot! I usually wear a 9 1/2 narrow or 9 medium. I ordered these boots in a 9 1/2 and they are too narrow across the toe! I am planning to exchange them for a 10, and hoping they fit.

Was this review helpful to you?  Yes or No ( Report this as inappropriate )

Very Beautiful Boot
2 Star Review   By Andi on Garnet Hill - Dec 31, 2012   

The foot is very narrow, more so than what was described. I have a fairly wide foot, so I ordered up one whole size, as directed, but still very tight fitting. Also, not as roomy in calves as expected. I would suggest ordering up another half or whole size larger.

Was this review helpful to you?  Yes or No ( Report this as inappropriate )

Simple and elegant
3 Star Review   By cfburke on Garnet Hill - Dec 31, 2012   

I really liked these boots, and loved the grey color! However, they were so wide on my calf. It looked ridiculous, even with pants tucked in. Unfortunately, they were sent back....

Was this review helpful to you?  Yes or No ( Report this as inappropriate )

High Quality Product
5 Star Review   By SHOPS46 on Garnet Hill - Dec 29, 2012   

this boot was a very high quality and I loved it--bur, I have a narrow foot and the front of my foot was comfortable but my heel is too narrow and walking in them--my heel raised completely off the bed of the boot--for me Italian of Spanish made are the only ones that come close to fitting. I really,really loved these boots(high quality) and tried to make it work with different socks & insole inserts but to no avail--I was very sad to send them back

Was this review helpful to you?  Yes or No ( Report this as inappropriate )

These boots were made for walking!!
5 Star Review   By starrydaughter on Garnet Hill - Dec 24, 2012   

The boots are well-made and comfortable. It does run narrow and so was glad I took the advice of other reviews to order half- size up. I wear an 8 and ordered an 8.5 in the brown. The brown is a rich, chocolate brown. Wore them for the first time all day yesterday and found them to be very comfortable. Another plus- I bought them for 40% off the sale price which was great! I'm considering purchasing the black as well.

Was this review helpful to you?  Yes or No ( Report this as inappropriate )

Nice but not for me
4 Star Review   By KKinMadtown on Garnet Hill - Dec 24, 2012   

I have purchased two pairs of these boots: one for me, and one for my daughter. I love them - they fit well, are comfortable and stylish. Unfortunately, they did not work for my daughter. She wears a size 11 shoe, and most boots in that size are just too wide in the calf. Same problem here, so sadly hers will be returned.

Was this review helpful to you?  Yes or No ( Report this as inappropriate )

Very Beautiful Boot
4 Star Review   By Andi on Garnet Hill - Dec 19, 2012   

I love these boots. The quality of the leather and the sturdiness of the soles make them a lasting and beautiful pair of boots. I have a very narrow foot with a high arch and these fit me so well. The only reason I didn't give them 5 stars is that one of the boots cuts into my ankle because of the stiffness of the heel support. I think with time it will soften or maybe with the help of a cobbler but for now it is causing a bruise.

Was this review helpful to you?  Yes or No ( Report this as inappropriate )

Love These
5 Star Review   By Texasshopgal on Garnet Hill - Dec 15, 2012   

I bought these boots in gray. They run true to size for me and are narrow which is great for me since my foot is narrow and I usually swim in boots. A perfect fit for me. I like the full length zipper on the inside.

Was this review helpful to you?  Yes or No ( Report this as inappropriate )

Excellent!
5 Star Review   By Peanut2 on Garnet Hill - Dec 12, 2012   

I love these boots... The leather is very subtle, and the fit is great. I did order 1/2 size up and am happy I did. They are a bit roomy, but not a problem in a flat boot. I wear them all day with no problem.

Was this review helpful to you?  Yes or No ( Report this as inappropriate )

Beautiful
5 Star Review   By cas46 on Garnet Hill - Dec 11, 2012   

I just tried them on and love them. I'm a small size 7 with a very high arch, and the 7.5 is perfect - tight going on but once my foot is in very comfortable. Since they are leather I'm sure they will conform to my feet with time. I'm 5'4'' , so the hight is a bit high in the back as the leather is new, but, again, I'm sure it will soften. They look great with leggings, and have plenty of room to tuck jeans in. Like the last pair of boots I bought from Garnet Hill, I'm sure I will be wearing these for several years.

Was this review helpful to you?  Yes or No ( Report this as inappropriate )

Great Boots
5 Star Review   By Jupu on Garnet Hill - Dec 8, 2012   

I absolutely LOVE these boots- they are beautiful leather, the look is right on trend for equestrian boots and the fit is just as the web site says- I usually wear a 9 and ordered 9.5 and it fit perfectly. It takes a little push to get your foot into the boot but once in they fit like a glove. Easy side zip lets you tuck in your jeans without having to shove the jeans into your boot since the boot is not a pull on...they are a real deal right now-$50 off and I hit a sale 30% off -the price for the quality of these boots makes them a must buy!

Was this review helpful to you?  Yes or No ( Report this as inappropriate )

Beautiful but narrow
4 Star Review   By SegoLily on Garnet Hill - Dec 2, 2012   

I was so disappointed that I had to send them back. I ordered a whole size larger than my normal shoe size based on previous reviews, but they were still a little too narrow for my comfort. But, they are beautiful boots!

Was this review helpful to you?  Yes or No ( Report this as inappropriate )

Cute, But Uncomfortable
3 Star Review   By Yogajacqui on Garnet Hill - Nov 29, 2012   

I love the look of these boots; the amount of detailing is just perfect. Unfortunately, the comfort and overall feel of the boot did not meet expectations. The leather is very thin and stiff, which I would have been ok with, if the footbed was comfortable. The edge of the footbed, by my ankle bone, had a rather obvious and sharp edge. As much as I wanted to keep these boots, my common sense won out, as I know I wouldn't be happy wearing them for more than an hour or two.

Was this review helpful to you?  Yes or No ( Report this as inappropriate )

nice boots until.......
4 Star Review   By Sandyhud on Garnet Hill - Nov 20, 2012   

Love these boots, nice leather, great height, ordered up a half size which worked great for me, heres the thing when I put them on to wear them for the event they were purchased for the zipper on the left boot came detached from the leather in a 3 inch section. Not a happy customer and just to be clear they were anything but tight These boots are way too expensive to be doing this,that said I am exchanging for another pair. Stay tuned!

Was this review helpful to you?  Yes or No ( Report this as inappropriate )

Excellent Purchase!
5 Star Review   By Cory on Garnet Hill - Nov 11, 2012   

As other reviews state, the boots run a little small/narrow in the toe box. I have used a shoe stretch product to ease the leather in that area and create a little more width for my toes! This is not unusual for me because I have narrow heels and a wider foot towards my toes. I love the style and the quality of the boots, they are very nice leather, and are also leather lined. (Nowadays, many "leather" boots actually have manmade linings, which makes them unbreathable, hot, and damp if you wear them for several hours) These are comfortable, easily wearable all day, well made, and great looking!

Was this review helpful to you?  Yes or No ( Report this as inappropriate )

Great Boot
4 Star Review   By tryingtogetthelook on Garnet Hill - Nov 11, 2012   

I have mixed feelings about these boots. I am thrilled to find flat boots that are high enough to come close to my knees. At 5'10", that is unusual. They are narrow so, as recommended, I ordered size 11 instead of my usual size 10. It's a fight to get my foot in, but once in they seem to be comfortable. I haven't found any other reviews that mention an odor, but my boots have a distinctive foul odor. After airing in the garage for more than a month, it diminished somewhat, so I've decided to keep them.

Was this review helpful to you?  Yes or No ( Report this as inappropriate )

Beautiful Boot
5 Star Review   By Ouch on Garnet Hill - Nov 4, 2012   

These boots work great for my skinny feet. I am very happy with the fit of these boots. The leather is super soft. I was amazed that I wore my boots all day and my feet had no pains, They are every comfortable.

Was this review helpful to you?  Yes or No ( Report this as inappropriate )

Pretty - Just not Comfortable
5 Star Review   By JMTD on Garnet Hill - Nov 4, 2012   

Good purchase. Soft leather and quite comfortable. I got a 1/2 size larger and am happy with that.

Was this review helpful to you?  Yes or No ( Report this as inappropriate )

Extraordinarily poor sizing.
1 Star Review   By JaneyL on Garnet Hill - Oct 30, 2012   

Reading the reviews telling how narrow these are, I ordered a size bigger than usual. I couldn't get my foot in. I've now ordered a size 21/2 times bigger. I'm hoping they fit.

Was this review helpful to you?  Yes or No ( Report this as inappropriate )

Very Beautiful Boot
4 Star Review   By Andi on Garnet Hill - Oct 27, 2012   

I bought these boots in gray and they are very classy and made from a fine soft leather. I took the recommendation and ordered up a size and they fit very well. I have long legs and these actually hit me right below the knees. Have had a lot of compliments about them!

Was this review helpful to you?  Yes or No ( Report this as inappropriate )

Gabriella riding boots
4 Star Review   By NurseAttorney on Garnet Hill - Oct 27, 2012   

They are beautiful, but hard to get on, once on they are a little tight but I am hoping they will stretch. shirley

Was this review helpful to you?  Yes or No ( Report this as inappropriate )

Poor fit
5 Star Review   By Natchan on Garnet Hill - Oct 25, 2012   

I love these Italian boots from Garnet Hill-they are beautiful and sturdy, classy and timeless. To be honest, I normally don't think twice about spending the extra money on designer boots, but these Garnet Hill Gabriella boots are better than the department store boots that cost two or three times more. I got a great deal on these, too--used a 25% coupon. They are narrow, and since I like wearing thick socks with my boots, I ordered a full size up... and it's sooo comfortable. The circumference is just a tad bit big, but I think it still looks great on my petite frame. I actually like that there are zippers on these boots, on the inner-sides of the legs. I might just get another pair in another color. :)

Was this review helpful to you?  Yes or No ( Report this as inappropriate )

GREAT LEATHER
5 Star Review   By NCKK on Garnet Hill - Oct 25, 2012   

Great look and fit, except the forefoot was too narrow. Even with wear, I did not think they would ever be comfortable. Had to return them.

Was this review helpful to you?  Yes or No ( Report this as inappropriate )

Classy
5 Star Review   By kayakbutte on Garnet Hill - Oct 23, 2012   

Beautiful boots. Fits true to size. Good fit around calves especially for those of us who work out.

Was this review helpful to you?  Yes or No ( Report this as inappropriate )

Good classic flat boot
5 Star Review   By skmadkap on Garnet Hill - Oct 23, 2012   

What a great purchase: Great fit, even for my wide foot and high arch. Zipper makes for easy on and off. Comfortable, very nice quality and styling...lots of compliments every time I wear these boots. Style is cut very high so probably not good if you have short calf. I don't and am delighted with the look and comfort. Love this boot! Looks just fab with dresses!

Was this review helpful to you?  Yes or No ( Report this as inappropriate )

Love my new boots
5 Star Review   By Mom2six on Garnet Hill - Oct 21, 2012   

These boots are awesome! Beautiful detail and style. Fantastic quality! My husband especially loves them! The toe box does fit a bit snug, but still fits comfortable. I ordered my regular size as I am in between a 8.5 and 9. Ordered a size 9 which is what I normally wear in most shoes. Just a bit pricy, but now I think worth it.

Was this review helpful to you?  Yes or No ( Report this as inappropriate )

Great boots
5 Star Review   By nane on Garnet Hill - Oct 19, 2012   

As a former Midwestern gal (now living in LA) I just can't think about boots in any way BUT purposeful -- to keep my feet dry from the rain or because of the snow. I am probably never going to wear heeled boots (booties, yes, boots, no). I have been looking for a black pair since I purchased a brown pair last year -- never realizing that black was really the color that would work best for me. I wore the boots on the plane to from LAX to JFK and then all day and couldn't be happier. They are a great product at a great price -- maybe I'll have to think about another pair in grey? I would HIGHLY recommend these boots -- and yes...buy them in the half size larger than your normal sizel

Was this review helpful to you?  Yes or No ( Report this as inappropriate )

Size up
3 Star Review   By sher59 on Garnet Hill - Oct 14, 2012   

The boots run slightly small and narrow. Also, there is an exposed zipper which I did not expect, and which was the reason I returned the boots. Otherwise the styling was really nice, and the boot leather was of good quality and lined. I really wanted to love this boot, but the exposed zipper was a real turn-off.

Was this review helpful to you?  Yes or No ( Report this as inappropriate )

Sad these didn't work out
4 Star Review   By TallMama on Garnet Hill - Oct 12, 2012   

Because I do have athletic calves, it is not easy for me to find a boot that works. This one does! However, I imagine the shaft would be very roomy on the average size calf. Top quality, simple and gorgeous. They do hit high, but I like that. Not sure I will be taking long walks in these but they look great for the office with skirts and dresses!

Was this review helpful to you?  Yes or No ( Report this as inappropriate )

Very comfortable, well made
4 Star Review   By SkinnyGirl on Garnet Hill - Oct 10, 2012   

This boot worked perfectly with skinny jeans. The grey color is lovely. I ordered up one size as some others suggested it runs small-that was a good decision. The heel box is a little challenging to fit on but then it fits comfortably. Not tight around the calf and I have athletic calves. Overall good value. I will wear these often.

Was this review helpful to you?  Yes or No ( Report this as inappropriate )

Beyond expectations
5 Star Review   By Mathgirl on Garnet Hill - Oct 9, 2012   

I am rarely disappointed with Garnet Hill but I have never purchased shoes or boots before so I was not sure what to expect - I was not disappointed! These boots fit like a glove, are extremely comfortable, even with no socks! Wore them the first time walking around NYC! Size reviews were right on - I am not very tall or thin and they fit fine around my calves and I am able to tuck in leggings and skinny jeans.

Was this review helpful to you?  Yes or No ( Report this as inappropriate )

Disappointed
2 Star Review   By Mandragore on Garnet Hill - Oct 9, 2012   

These boots look better in the catalog. Even though I was disappointed in how they looked I still tried them on and because they were too big everywhere I sent them back.

Was this review helpful to you?  Yes or No ( Report this as inappropriate )

great boots
5 Star Review   By momofaeac on Garnet Hill - Oct 8, 2012   

Love, love these boots. Comfortable and soft leather. Ordered 1/2 size up and they fit perfect.

Was this review helpful to you?  Yes or No ( Report this as inappropriate )

Exceeded Expectations
5 Star Review   By katball on Garnet Hill - Oct 8, 2012   

I've been looking for a comfortable, yet stylish boot that would work for me. All too often they are too tight in the calves or have stretch elastic to allow for the required width. These fit perfectly and are just the look I was hoping to find. (A great price reduction too!)

Was this review helpful to you?  Yes or No ( Report this as inappropriate )

Beautiful but too narrow
4 Star Review   By CJPN on Garnet Hill - Oct 8, 2012   

Im 5'5" petite, about 110. I found these wide in the calves. I have avg size calves. The leather is a bit stiff, I may be a bit fussy. I think overall they are nice, but didnt meet my fussy quality standard. I think they would take some time to break in. I bought a 8 in black and usually wear 7.5 - the footbed was a good fit. I returned these - but will try something else.

Was this review helpful to you?  Yes or No ( Report this as inappropriate )

Very Beautiful Boot
5 Star Review   By Andi on Garnet Hill - Oct 8, 2012   

the boots are beautiful, but a little narrow in the toes, so, unfortunately, I had to send them back. I have medium width feet, but don't like a narrow toe box, and these were just too tight.

Was this review helpful to you?  Yes or No ( Report this as inappropriate )

nice quality boots
5 Star Review   By Jankinclifford on Garnet Hill - Oct 8, 2012   

I was fortunate to get these wonderful boots on sale but I feel they are well worth the regular price. The leather is sumptuous and rich. The style is timeless. It is very necessary to follow the fit instructions. The usual rule of thumb, to go up a half size in boots, definitely applies with these boots. Going up a full size for high arches is also good advice. Take your time and think it through carefully before picking a size. You will be glad you did and thrilled with your purchase. I know that I am!

Was this review helpful to you?  Yes or No ( Report this as inappropriate )

Beautiful boot, terrible design
2 Star Review   By effiejane on Garnet Hill - Oct 5, 2012   

I've been looking for a flat, elegant boot for a long time, so I was really looking forward to loving these boots. Even the comments about the width of the calf didn't deter me--I figured I could always tuck my pants/leggings in and still have a great look. The problem, which was mentioned by at least one other poster, is that the back of the boot is cut too high--when I walk, climb stairs or sit down, it digs into the back of my knee. Generally, a boot will slant downwards in the back in order to address this problem. Such a shame...beautiful quality, but the boots are going back.

Was this review helpful to you?  Yes or No ( Report this as inappropriate )

Beautiful boots but too big in the calves for me
4 Star Review   By Carenhh on Garnet Hill - Sep 26, 2012   

This is a beautiful, well-made boot in exactly the style I wanted, but it really needs to be labeled "for large calves." I don't have skinny calves (in fact, there was a time when I had some trouble finding knee-high boots that weren't too snug in the calves), so when I tried these boots on, I was amazed to see at least a 2-inch "gap" around the top. I could pinch up about that much extra leather around the ankles, too. In addition to the gap, there's a gusset that would allow the boots to expand another inch or so. I think the boots would be roomy on anyone whose calves are less than 15 inches.

Was this review helpful to you?  Yes or No ( Report this as inappropriate )

Wonderful boots
5 Star Review   By nean on Garnet Hill - Sep 24, 2012   

I got these boots at 20%, which helped offset the high price, and they are definitely worth the expense. The leather is soft, the gray is a pure gray rather than a brown gray, and I was able to wear them for a full day of walking right out of the box. My calves are muscular, and sometimes don't fit in knee high boots, but these fit great, and I got lots of compliments.

Was this review helpful to you?  Yes or No ( Report this as inappropriate )

beautiful, but
3 Star Review   By workinggirl on Garnet Hill - Sep 17, 2012   

very cute boots, loved the buckles - but shaft was way too big (I have normal size calves). also seemed like they were too tall - hit at the joint behind my knee in a funny way. sad to send them back but just not the right fit for me, so have to give them overall average rating.

Was this review helpful to you?  Yes or No ( Report this as inappropriate )

Love these
5 Star Review   By Snik on Garnet Hill - Sep 16, 2012   

Great looking boot. I ordered the 8 1/2, and the fit is snug. However, I think they will loosen up with wear. The shaft of the boot is wide enough to tuck in skinny jeans or leggings. I've been looking for a dressy black riding boot, and these fit the bill.

Was this review helpful to you?  Yes or No ( Report this as inappropriate )

Love these boots
4 Star Review   By taxi on Garnet Hill - Sep 6, 2012   

I just received these boots in the mail and am SO impressed! They are a beautiful color, and very comfortable. I'm not sure why the previous reviewer stated that the calves of the boots run so large that she can fit her arm in along with her leg?? I too have what I would consider 'average' calves, and they fit perfectly. Actually they are a little snug considering that I intend to wear them with skinny jeans! (this won't be a problem, as leather stretches a bit as you wear it). Overall I would highly recommend these boots!

Was this review helpful to you?  Yes or No ( Report this as inappropriate )

Beautiful Classic Boot
5 Star Review   By LParker on Garnet Hill - Sep 5, 2012   

These are beautiful, classic, well-crafted Italian boots. The picture does not even do them justice. I have the brown which is a rich lovely color. The calf is wide enough to fit over jeans but they will look lovely with skirts as well. The foot runs a bit narrow so I would size up a half size unless you have a very narrow foot.

Was this review helpful to you?  Yes or No ( Report this as inappropriate )

Very wide calves!
4 Star Review   By Jackier on Garnet Hill - Aug 31, 2012   

I was excited to get these boots on a special pricing deal. They are good looking, simple and stylish but the calves are really big. I could fit my arm inside the calf after zipping them up. I would say my calves are st least average size. If you have large calves these will be perfect for you. I will have to return them.

Was this review helpful to you?  Yes or No ( Report this as inappropriate )





Copyright ©2015 PriceGrabber.com, Inc. All Rights Reserved

Show Survey

Feedback

We want to improve your experience!

Please take a moment to answer the questions below:

How likely would you be to recommend PriceGrabber to a friend or colleague?

Not likely at all Neutral Extremely likely

What is your main purpose for visiting PriceGrabber today? (Optional)

What areas can PriceGrabber improve to better serve your needs? (Optional)

How easy was it to find what you were looking for? (Optional)

Gender (Optional)

Age (Optional)

Annual Income (Optional)

Comments (Optional)

Authorized Retailers Offer